NICOLE VS. LINDSAY
Lindsay Lohan (right) wore a blooming Jean Paul Gaultier top to a New York City party; pal Nicole Richie sported the same shirt to an L.A. bash. Who's finer in floral – the Simple Life star or the Just My Luck actress?
GARCELLE VS. KELLY
Kelly Rowland (right) hit a Vibe Vixen fete in New York City in crimson BCBG Max Azria, the same frock Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon once donned. Who's more chic in chiffon – the actress or the chanteuse?
MENA VS. KELLY
Out in L.A., Kelly Osbourne (right) keeps it basic in a black-and-white blazer; Mena Suvari buttons up the look at a Hollywood premiere. Who's a better contrast – the American Beauty or the British rock progeny?
RACHAEL VS. JENNY
Jenny McCarthy (right) stepped out in New York City in a '50s-style Louis Verdad – the same dress Rachael Leigh Cook wore to an L.A. event. Who's prettier in polka dots – the Las Vegas guest star or the Life Laughs author?
LISA VS. PINK
For an Australian awards show, Pink (right) went glam in beaded Jenny Packham; Lisa Rinna wore the same gown to the Daytime Emmy Awards. Who's sexier in satin – the "Stupid Girls" singer or the Dancing with the Stars hoofer?
PARIS VS. BRITNEY
Out with Kevin Federline, Britney Spears (right) wore a fire-red version of the Rose & Lula dress that American Idol finalist Paris Bennett sported on the show. Who's sexier in the Marilyn-esque frock – the Idol wannabe or the pop idol?
KELLY VS. PETRA
Supermodel Petra Nemcova (right) looks divine in form-fitting Dolce & Gabbana at a New York City fete; Kelly Preston donned the same dress to the CMT Awards. Who's more fab in floral – Capt. Travolta's most frequent flier or the Czech Republic's favorite catwalker?
MANDY VS. SELMA
Selma Blair (right) showed up in champagne Marc Jacobs at a recent Hollywood party; Mandy Moore wore a black version to the Late Show. Who's lovelier in lace – the American Dreamz star or the Dirty Shame actress?
JESSICA VS. INÉS
At her Hollywood premiere for The Lost City, Spanish actress Inés Sastre (right) shines in an Alberta Ferretti frock, the same one Jessica Alba once rocked. Who's more stunning in silk – the California Honey or the City girl?
FERGIE VS. GABRIELLE
Gabrielle Union (right) hits a Las Vegas Maxim party in belted Gucci – the same dress Fergie wore to the Golden Globes. Who's cooler in khaki – the "My Humps" singer or the Honeymooners actress?
NICKY VS. TORI
At a party for her new VH1 show So NoTORIous, Tori Spelling (right) wore the same bell-sleeved, cleavage-bearing Tracey Feith dress that Nicky Hilton donned at a bash in Las Vegas. But which blonde heiress is more of a Renaissance woman?
DREW VS. KELLY
Kelly Osbourne (right) sported emerald Gucci to a recent London awards ceremony; Drew Barrymore wore the same gown to the Golden Globes. Who's more glam in green – the Hollywood queen or the rock 'n' roll princess?
KATHERINE VS. KRISTIN
At an L.A. premiere, Laguna Beach's Kristin Cavallari (right) sparkled in the same Escada top that Katherine Heigl wore to a Golden Globes party. Who shines brightest – the Grey's Anatomy gal or the blonde bombshell?
RACHEL VS. AMBER
Amber Valletta (right) looked dainty in Derek Lam at a luncheon in Beverly Hills; Rachel Bilson wore the same frock to the Teen Choice Awards. Who's more delicate in Derek – the O.C. star or the supermodel?
LINDSAY VS. MARIAH
At a New York premiere, Lindsay Lohan (left) flashes a peek at her Louis Vuitton miniskirt – the same one Mariah Carey wore for a shoot in Paris. Who looks best – the teen queen or the reigning diva?
Source
